| Name/Film |
Studio |
Pros |
Cons |
| Todd Haynes/I'm Not There |
Weinstein |
|
|
| Tim Burton/Sweeney Todd |
DW/Para |
|
|
| Julian Schnabel/Diving Bell |
Mmx |
|
|
| Mike Nichols/Charlie Wilson |
Uni |
|
|
| Coens/No Country... |
Mmx |
|
|
| Joe Wright/Atonement |
Focus |
|
|
| Sidney Lumet/Before the Devil |
ThinkFilm |
|
|
| P.T. Anderson/There Will Be Blood |
P. Vantage |
|
|
| Ben Affleck/Gone Baby Gone |
Mmx |
|
|
| Sean Penn/Into the Wild |
P. Vantage |
|
|
| Ridley Scott/American Gangster |
Uni |
|
|
| Denzel Washington/The Great Debaters |
Weinstein |
|
|
| David Cronenberg/Eastern Promises |
Focus |
|
|
| Name/Film |
Studio |
Pros |
Cons |
| Philip Seymour Hoffman/The Savages |
Searchlt |
The actor's actor--and he's everywhere this year |
He got the lead one already--time for a supporting one? |
| James McAvoy/Atonement |
Focus |
|
Face may be too fresh; young men don't usually get lead noms |
| Mathieu Amalric/The Diving Bell |
Mmx |
|
Very small film |
| Denzel Washington/American Gangster or The Great
Debaters |
Uni/WeinCo |
|
May split votes |
| George Clooney/Michael Clayton |
Warner |
The only people who don't like him are hardcore conservatives. Of
which there are some in AMPAS, true. |
Not really the kind of emotionally affective role usually nominated |
| Daniel Day-Lewis/There Will Be Blood |
P. Vantage |
Well overdue, and a very unusual role |
Stiff competition; TWBB will need kickass performance |
| Johnny Depp/Sweeney Todd |
DW/Para |
AMPAS has been itching to finally give him a statue. |
Is this really his tour-de-force role? |
| Tom Hanks/Charlie Wilson |
Uni |
Tom's back! Yay! |
In a comedy |
| Brad Pitt/Jesse James |
Warner |
|
|
| Viggo Mortensen/Eastern Promises |
Focus |
Could this finally be his year for attention? |
He's still an outsider, and the film is still under a lot of radars |
| Emile Hirsch/Into the Wild |
P. Vantage |
Director Sean Penn will pimp him like a cheap whore |
Unknown, and far too young for this category |
| Don Cheadle/Talk to Me |
|
|
|
| Josh Brolin/No Country... |
Mmx |
|
|
| Name/Film |
Studio |
Pros |
Cons |
| Amy Adams |
Dis |
Basically carries the entire film; previous nom means she's known |
Comedy role |
| Ellen Page |
Srchlt |
Adorable and up-and-coming--the academy loves those |
very young and untested; small film |
| Laura Linney/The Savages |
Srchlt |
So overdue it's not funny |
Small film |
| Keira Knightley/Atonement |
Focus |
Gorgeous, better than many her age and type, and a perfect role for
her |
None. She WILL be nommed. Will she win? No idea |
| Cate Blanchett/Elizabeth: TGA |
Uni |
This is an opportunity to right a nine-year wrong |
The film itself was terrible |
| Julie Christie/Away From Her |
Lions |
A renaissance role for a classic |
Low profile film |
| Angelina Jolie/A Mighty Heart |
|
She's pretty. And apparently good in this |
Very low-profile film. Doubtful AMPAS is that desperate for nominees |
| |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
| Name/Film |
Studio |
Pros |
Cons |
| Casey Affleck/Gone Baby Gone |
Mmx |
|
|
| Javier Bardem/No Country |
Mmx |
|
|
| Philip Seymour Hoffman/Charlie Wilson |
Uni |
He's always on a short list for everything he does, and this is a
kickass role for him |
He may split votes. He should at least get a nom, though |
| Tom Wilkinson/Michael Clayton |
Warner |
Consistently good work, and consistently overlooked |
Too much competition for a lower-profile film |
| Russell Crowe/American Gangster |
Uni |
|
Has his bad karma finally expired? |
| Albert Finney/Before the Devil |
ThinkFilm |
|
|
| Max Von Sydow/Diving Bell |
Mmx |
|
|